Tomlin and his challenge record

I've seen a lot of people complain about his challenges over the years, and honestly, there have been some bad ones, but did any of you see Andy Reid's mast-piece challenge performance Sunday? This guy called some DUMB challenge's Sunday, and apparently, it's something Bengals fan know all to well. Is Tomlin really that bad? I think he looks good in comparison to Reid.

Tomlin doesn't make many dumb challenges. I know there was one challenge (I can't remember the circumstance) where I thought, "Uh, what the hell are you challenging that for? It's not even close." But there haven't been too many of those. With that said, I don't think his record is very good. He loses a lot more than he wins (at least that's my perception).

I don't know if there's any coach with a 'winning' challenge record, actually.

Dodens Grav wrote:

I don't know if there's any coach with a 'winning' challenge record, actually.

Possibly. I don't pay a whole lot of attention to what other coaches are doing in that regard.

I recall reading a while ago that Tom Coughlin had the best win percentage, and I think it was like 45 or 47 or something. Let's also not forget that now that all turnovers and scores are automatically reviewed, there are a lot less obvious things to challenge, so I wouldn't be surprised if it negatively affects a lot of coaches' challenge percentage.